Softness baseline
Wheat · pan · enriched
A baseline soft white pan loaf with 5% sugar and 5% oil: a control bake that gives a scale for comparing tangzhong, potato, soaker, and yudane.
Live timing needs JavaScript enabled.
Calculated for the current time; the worksheet lets you set any start.
Recipe
Current recipe
For baking now: the final working formula, ingredients, steps, and baking worksheet.
Taste & texture
A mild, lightly sweet crumb with a fine, even cell structure that slices cleanly without tearing. The crust bakes to a thin, golden shell — soft enough to compress under a thumb rather than shatter. Flavor is plain and wheaty with a very subtle yeasty note; sugar at 5% adds warmth without making the loaf taste sweet. Oil keeps the crumb plush and slightly moist at day one; texture holds reasonably at 24 h and begins to tighten by 48 h — typical for an oil-enriched loaf without dairy or starch-paste additions. Aroma is gentle and toasty.
As described by: King Arthur Baking: Our Favorite Sandwich Bread , King Arthur Baking: White Sandwich Bread
Baking worksheet
Good to know
Why does S2-A1 sit in this place in the course?
S2-A is used after the main S2, once baseline softness mechanisms are already familiar.
Can several parameters be changed at once?
No. The lesson is built around one variable; other changes belong in a separate version.
What counts as the main result?
Rate the crumb on a 5-point scale right after cooling, at 24 h, and at 72 h: elasticity, moisture, aroma. If two consecutive bakes produce the same score, the scale is working. This baseline is needed for the next lessons with tangzhong and fermented dairy liquid.
A baseline soft loaf is the most useful bread to bake well before you start chasing softening tricks. This is a plain white pan loaf at 65% hydration with just 5% sugar and 5% oil — enough to make the crumb tender and slow staling, but not so much that it reads as a brioche or a sweet bun. Bake it carefully, cool it fully, and you have a reference point you can taste every softening method against: tangzhong, a potato addition, a soaker, fermented dairy liquid, or yudane all become “how much softer than this loaf,” instead of a vague impression.
How It’s Baked Around the World and Why
The plain soft white pan loaf is one of the most widely baked breads on earth, and almost every baking culture has its own version of exactly this idea — a little sugar, a little fat, a tight pan, a tender crumb.
In Britain and across the Commonwealth it is the everyday sandwich tin loaf: strong flour, a touch of sugar and fat, baked in a closed-top or open-top tin so the crumb stays fine and the crust soft enough to slice for toast. North American sandwich bread and the “milk and honey” white loaf sit in the same family, usually nudged a bit richer with milk solids. In Japan the same logic is pushed to its softest extreme as shokupan, where a tangzhong or yudane is added on top of this kind of base — which is exactly why a plain version makes such a good control: shokupan is “this loaf, plus a starch paste.” Mexican pan de caja, French pain de mie, and Chinese steamed-then-baked milk breads are all regional dialects of the same sentence.
Why this shape and these numbers recur is practical. A pan supports a slack, soft dough that would spread if left free-form, and the walls trap steam so the crumb sets moist and even. Around 5% sugar feeds browning and holds water without choking the yeast; around 5% oil shortens gluten strands just enough to give a plush bite and keep the loaf fresh an extra day. Bakers everywhere converged on this balance because it is the cheapest, most reliable way to get a soft, sliceable, slow-staling everyday bread — which is precisely why it is the right baseline to measure fancier softening methods against.
Theory
A soft pan loaf gets its character from three levers working together: a generous but controlled hydration, a small dose of sugar, and a small dose of fat. Sugar feeds crust colour and holds moisture; oil shortens gluten for a plush bite and slows staling; the pan and a moderate bake keep the crumb tender rather than crusty. Judge each stage by the dough, not the clock — readiness at fermentation and proof is a state, not a number of minutes.
| Lever | Practical takeaway | | --- | --- | | Sugar 5% | colour and moisture retention without slowing the yeast | | Oil 5% | plush bite, finer crumb, an extra day of freshness | | Hydration 65% | soft, sliceable crumb; judge stickiness by temperature, not by adding flour | | Bake | check doneness by internal temperature and crust state, not colour alone |
Formula
| Ingredient | Grams | % to flour | | --- | ---: | ---: | | Strong white bread flour | 400 g | 100 | | Water | 260 g | 65 | | Sugar | 20 g | 5 | | Vegetable oil | 20 g | 5 | | Salt | 8 g | 2 | | Fresh yeast | 6 g | 1.5 |
Real hydration is the full 65%: 260 g water to 400 g flour. Sugar and oil sit at 5% each, just enough to soften the crumb without turning the loaf into an enriched dough.
If Something Goes Wrong
- Crumb dense or tight → mix to fuller gluten development and do not cut the final proof short; judge readiness by the poke test, not the clock.
- Dome cracked or shape uneven → likely overproof or a weak seam: the poke should return slowly, not instantly, and tuck the seam firmly underneath.
- Loaf stales fast (soft when fresh, hard the next day) → it was stored open or too warm; wrap in a towel or bag and hold around 22 °C, and check that the 5% sugar and oil are actually in the dough.
- Crust pale or leathery → the oven was underheated or the bake too short; preheat fully (the ceramic pan needs the extra 10 °C) and finish by internal temperature, 94–96 °C.
- Loaf too sweet or greasy for an everyday loaf → the sugar or oil crept above 5%; return to 5%/5% before changing anything else.
Theory Sources
- King Arthur Baking: tangzhong and bread softness — source for softening proportions and technique.
- King Arthur Baking: potato bread — reference for a potato-softened soft loaf.
- King Arthur Baking: storing yeast bread — how storage affects softness and staling.
Ingredients
Change any amount — the rest rescale by the bread’s formula.
| Component | Grams | Baker's % |
|---|---|---|
| Strong white bread flour | g | 100% |
| Water | g | 65% |
| Sugar | g | 5% |
| Vegetable oil | g | 5% |
| Salt | g | 2% |
| Fresh yeast | g | 1.5% |
Ingredient details
Strong white bread flour
- Brand the author uses
- MukaMuka 13.5% protein (mukamuka.ru)
- Alternatives
- Aleyna Vivapol 12-13%, King Arthur Bread Flour 12.7%
Water
- Brand the author uses
- Tap water through Barrier Iron x2 filter
- Alternatives
- any filtered or bottled drinking water
Sugar
- Brand the author uses
- White sugar, no specific brand
- Alternatives
- any white sugar; for brown — Mistral demerara
Salt
- Brand the author uses
- Pink Himalayan salt
- Alternatives
- sea or table salt (avoid iodized)
Fresh yeast
- Brand the author uses
- Lux (Voronezh) fresh or Ayrek (homemade)
- Alternatives
- any fresh yeast in 100 g pack
Conditions and equipment
Conditions
- Constraint
- do not change the baseline formula without a separate version
- Lesson-closure state
- The lesson is closed if the baseline bake has been repeated twice with the same result, and the sheet records assessment points for future comparisons.
Equipment
- Pan
- Emile Henry Petit Moule Cake 1.1 L (ceramic, 22×9.5×6.5 cm) or a similar-volume metal 9×5 inch pan
- Mixing
- planetary mixer with a hook, or hand mixing with recorded time and temperature
- Bake
- home oven, probe thermometer, cooling rack
Nutrition: how to eat this bread
Bread nutrition facts
Per 100 g of bread
268 kcal
protein 7.8 g · fat 4.2 g · carbs 48.9 g
Per slice (50 g)
134 kcal
protein 3.9 g · fat 2.1 g · carbs 24.5 g
Automatic calculation from USDA + Skurikhin database for the baked loaf after evaporation. Numbers are approximate: 1) the database covers ingredients, not finished dough; 2) bake water loss is assumed at 10% — actual loss depends on crust, time, and pan. Add 5–10% in calorie trackers if needed.
Bread is a source of starch and energy. Its nutrition depends on flour, fermentation, salt, enrichment, serving size, and the rest of the plate.
- Digestion
- More whole grain, fibre, and fermentation usually mean longer satiety. White flour eaten alone is generally digested faster.
- Helpful or harmful
- Bread is not poison or medicine by itself. Overall diet matters; current guidance prioritizes whole grains, vegetables, fruits, and pulses.
- Amount
- For most learning tastings, 1–2 slices, about 30–80 g, is enough depending on loaf density.
- Best pairings
- Pair with protein, vegetables, and moderate fat; avoid making it a large standalone portion with sweet drinks or sweet spreads.
How to eat
- Taste the bread plain for learning, then eat it as part of a balanced plate.
- Slice dense rye thinner; with soft white bread, make sure softness does not automatically increase the serving.
Limits
- Wheat and rye breads contain gluten.
- For medical conditions, adjust bread type and serving size with a clinician or dietitian.
Instructions
-
Setup
Weigh ingredients, prepare the pan and the working sheet.
-
Mix
Combine ingredients until cohesive, then mix to a smooth soft dough.
-
Bulk fermentation
Leave the dough to noticeable rise and gas saturation. Judge by state, not only by minutes.
-
Shape
Gently degas, shape a tight log, and place in a greased pan.
-
Final proof
Proof to puffiness and slow finger-poke return.
-
Bake
Bake by the working-sheet regime to the target internal temperature.
-
Cool and assess
Cool completely, slice, and record the conclusion by the lesson's main variable.
Version history
- v1.0May 24, 2026in development
- Problem
- S2-A needs a lesson: the softness baseline scale.
- Change
- Created the S2-A1 lesson: softness baseline scale.